“What do I need to do to be effective in this situation?”
I remember this question from the specialist training in dialectical behaviour therapy, or DBT, that I undertook after qualifying as a Doctor of Psychology. I trained as part of a team in the UK health service, working with people with personality disorders and complex emotional difficulties. My work with anger began there.
It is a question that asks you to consider what your next action will achieve. You may have a good reason to be angry. You may also be about to do something that makes it harder to get the result you need.
Perhaps you want an apology, but the conversation has become an exchange of insults. Perhaps you want someone to stop assuming you will help, but you keep agreeing because saying no feels uncomfortable. In each situation, I would want to understand what matters to you before deciding what would help.
What I mean by effective
DBT includes effectiveness among its mindfulness skills. It involves knowing your goal, considering the situation as it actually is and choosing a response that serves that goal. 1
The question needs an answer more specific than “I want this sorted.” What would being sorted involve? An agreement about who does what? A clear refusal? Getting through tonight without another argument, followed by a conversation tomorrow?
You do not have to decide that your anger is wrong before asking this. Understanding a feeling and deciding whether to act on its urge are separate tasks. 2 You can say, “I am angry about what happened, and I need to decide how to address it.”
I would also look beyond whether a response brings immediate relief. Saying everything you have been holding back may feel satisfying. Agreeing to something you do not want may end an uncomfortable conversation. What happens afterwards matters too.
Three things that may matter at once
DBT’s interpersonal skills ask us to consider the practical outcome, the relationship and our self-respect. Their importance can differ from one situation to another. 3
The practical outcome is the change you want: a task completed, a decision made or an unwanted request declined.
The relationship concerns how you want to relate to this person beyond the disagreement. You may want to remain close, preserve a workable professional relationship or establish more distance.
Self-respect concerns whether you can stand over your own conduct. It includes being honest about what you can offer and taking your needs seriously.
These priorities can compete. You might want to decline a request and also want the person to be pleased with you. There may be no sentence that achieves both. The useful decision is which priority needs to guide you here, and what you are willing to accept as a consequence.
The following examples are invented to show how I would reason through that decision. They are not accounts of particular clients.
Example 1: you are late, and the argument is making you later
You and your partner agreed when to leave for an event. That time has passed. You are both finally ready, but you are angry because this has happened several times before.
You begin listing the previous occasions. Your partner disputes one of them. Now you are arguing about whose memory is correct while still standing at the door.
There are several things you might want: an apology, recognition that your time matters, a more reliable arrangement for future outings, and a chance to enjoy the event you planned to attend.
I would ask which of those needs attention first. If you still want to go, continuing the argument at the door could take you further from that immediate goal. You could say:
“I’m angry about how late we are. I want to get there now. Tomorrow, I want us to work out a departure time we can both keep.”
You may still feel angry as you leave. That does not make the decision pointless. You have chosen an action that serves the immediate aim without claiming that the recurring problem has been resolved.
The next part matters: return to the issue. What caused the difficulty? Was the departure time realistic? Was preparation left too late? Did one person think the agreement was flexible? Those questions could lead to a more useful arrangement than another argument about who always causes the delay.
If you repeatedly leave the discussion until later and never have it, the longer-term goal remains unattended. I would look at that honestly. Getting out of the door was one task; changing an arrangement that keeps causing resentment is another.
On another occasion, you might decide not to attend. Naming your priority helps you choose what to do in the situation you actually face.
Example 2: being effective means saying no
A relative tells the family that Sunday lunch will be at your home. They have not asked you. You already have plans.
You feel angry, but you imagine the objections if you refuse. You consider agreeing and cancelling your plans. Another possibility is an angry message listing every time they have taken you for granted.
I would bring the question back to the immediate decision: do you want to host this meal? In this example, you do not. You also want future arrangements to be discussed with you first.
A response could be:
“I’m not hosting on Sunday. I already have plans. Please ask me before arranging a meal at my house.”
That response gives the relative information they need. It does not require you to establish what kind of person they are or persuade them that your plans are sufficiently important.
They may be disappointed. They may say that everyone was looking forward to it. You can acknowledge that while keeping your answer: “I understand they were expecting it. I’m still not available to host.”
Here, effectiveness includes carrying out the refusal. If you say no and then prepare the meal because the relative objects, the arrangement you wanted to change continues.
This does not mean every family disagreement requires a firm refusal. You might willingly change your plans on another occasion. The distinction is whether you are making a choice you can stand over, having considered the circumstances, or agreeing mainly to end the discomfort while resentment grows.
The relative may still object. You can consider the practical consequences and how to maintain the relationship while carrying out your decision. A clear boundary gives you a decision to implement; it does not give you control over their feelings.
Six questions to use with your own situation
These questions show how I would apply the principle to a particular situation. Try them before a predictable difficulty or when reviewing something afterwards.
- What has actually happened? Describe the event. Separate what you know from what you think it means.
- What result do I need now, and what matters beyond today? Name a practical outcome and any recurring issue that needs attention.
- What matters most here: the outcome, the relationship or my self-respect? Consider where they conflict. You may have to accept that you cannot satisfy every priority equally.
- What do I feel like doing, and where is that likely to lead? Include what could happen during the interaction and afterwards.
- What action can I take that better serves my priority? Be specific about what you will say or do. “Be less angry” does not yet describe an action.
- What happened when I tried it, and what should I adjust? Review your behaviour and the result. Keep what helped and examine what did not.
I would not expect you to work through all six questions in the middle of an intense outburst. Choose a short, concrete response you can use first, such as putting down the phone before sending an insulting message. You can examine the fuller decision when you are able to think it through.
If you know the response you want but feel pulled towards attacking or punishing, my guide to opposite action for anger explains how to practise acting differently.
If you spend the intervening time repeatedly making the case against the other person, notice that too. My article on replaying arguments and anger rumination explores what can keep an argument going in your mind.
What if the other person still disagrees?
DBT recognises that other people and circumstances can prevent even skilful attempts from producing the outcome we want. Good communication improves the possibilities; it cannot guarantee cooperation. 3
If your request is refused, I would look at both your approach and the circumstances. Was the request clear? Could the person do what you asked? Was there room to negotiate? Did the conversation reveal a disagreement that remains unresolved?
Be careful about drawing either of two conclusions too quickly: “They disagreed, so I must have handled it badly,” or “I spoke calmly, so there is nothing for me to learn.” Their response is information to consider alongside what you did.
Being effective also leaves room to name wrongdoing and seek accountability. You can describe a broken agreement, challenge unfair treatment or ask for an apology. Considering your own response does not make you responsible for somebody else’s behaviour.
Where there is intimidation or danger, the immediate priority may be getting support or leaving safely. You do not have to keep negotiating to demonstrate that you can communicate well.
Putting the question to use
Choose a disagreement that you can think about clearly. Write down what you wanted, what you did and whether those two things fitted together. Then write the sentence or action you would try if a similar situation arose again.
You might discover that you needed to be more direct. You might discover that you pursued an apology while neglecting the practical change you wanted. That is something specific you can practise.
My guide to DBT for anger explains how to examine an episode and choose skills that fit it. For a broader explanation and the help available in Ireland, see my anger management guide.
Sources
- Linehan, M. M. DBT Skills Training Manual, Second Edition. Guilford Press, 2015. Mindfulness teaching notes, “Effectively,” pp. 211–212. Publisher’s teaching materials.
- Behavioral Tech Institute. The Role of Emotion Regulation in DBT, Part 1. Interview with Sara Schmidt, PhD, on emotional validation, factual fit and effectiveness. Read the explanation.
- Linehan, M. M. DBT Skills Training Manual, Second Edition. Guilford Press, 2015. Interpersonal effectiveness teaching notes on priorities, competing goals and limits of skills. Publisher’s teaching materials.
