Dr Elaine RyanDoctor of PsychologyStart Anger Management Course
Menu

Insights from Dr Elaine Ryan

Opposite action for anger: deciding what to do differently

Opposite action is a DBT skill that involves deliberately acting against an emotional urge when that urge is taking you in an unhelpful direction. With anger, the urge might be to attack, retaliate or punish someone through your withdrawal. The skill is intended to help change the emotional response through what you do. 1

The difficult part is deciding what would count as opposite action in your situation. You may have a real grievance. You may feel furious even after choosing your words carefully. You may wonder whether changing your response means letting somebody get away with what they did.

If you are new to the skill, my general guide to opposite action in DBT explains the principles using fear and avoidance. Here, I will work through the decisions that arise with anger.

My specialist training in dialectical behaviour therapy came after qualifying as a Doctor of Psychology, while I was working within a team in the UK health service with people with personality disorders and complex emotional difficulties. When I look at anger, I want to understand both what happened and what your response is doing. That distinction matters throughout this skill.

Two decisions to make before acting opposite

Does the anger, including its intensity and duration, fit what is happening?

Describe the event before deciding what it means. A colleague questioning a figure is observable. “She wants everybody to think I’m incompetent” is an interpretation. There may be evidence for it, but the strength of the feeling cannot establish the motive.

Ask whether the strength and duration of the anger match the event and its consequences. Include new information: discovering that a mistake was accidental may change how you understand it, even while the feeling takes time to settle. Anger can be understandable without every conclusion accurately reflecting the situation. 2

What would happen if I followed this particular urge?

This is a separate question. Someone may have treated you badly, and retaliating may still damage your position, hurt somebody else or prolong the dispute. You can recognise the wrongdoing and decide to act against that urge.

DBT allows for opposite action when the emotion does not fit the facts, including its strength or duration, or when acting on its urge would be ineffective. A real problem can also call for a request, a boundary or a practical solution. 1 These responses can work together.

I would therefore ask, “Which part of my response am I trying to change?” “Stop being angry” is too broad to guide you. “Stop trying to humiliate this person” identifies something you can do differently.

Choose an opposite to your actual urge

You need to be specific about what anger is pulling you towards. “I want to make a cutting remark” gives you a different task from “I want to refuse to speak until they suffer enough.”

For the first, you might choose a straightforward question and give the person room to answer. For the second, you might choose direct communication about what happened. Returning to a conversation is appropriate only if that contact is safe and serves a useful purpose.

DBT asks you to include how you act as well as the words you use: your expression, posture, voice and what you continue doing with your attention. A polite question delivered with a sneer can continue the attack.

Preparing the next accusation can keep your attention on reasons to attack, even while you are silent. Listening to the answer, opening your hands and speaking steadily change more of that response. The aim is to influence the anger through these changes, with practice across suitable occasions. 3

You can work on those parts while still feeling angry. There is no requirement to produce affection, forgive someone or resume a relationship you have decided to leave.

The following examples are invented to show the reasoning. They are not accounts of particular clients.

Example 1: accurate feedback feels like an attack

During a meeting, a colleague says, “I think the delivery costs have been counted twice in that total.”

Your face feels hot. You think, “She’s trying to make me look stupid.” You remember an error she made last month and want to bring it up in front of everyone.

Work out what you know

At this point, you know that your calculation has been questioned. You do not yet know whether it is wrong or why the colleague spoke up. Embarrassment may be part of what you are experiencing too.

I would look at what the urge is trying to achieve. Bringing up her earlier mistake might briefly move the attention away from you. It would also leave the present calculation unresolved and turn a work question into a personal contest.

An appropriate opposite response would involve becoming willing to examine the correction with her. You could say:

“Can you show me where you’re seeing the duplication?”

Then follow through. Look at the calculation she indicates. Let her finish. Keep your hands on the table instead of pointing at her, and use the volume you would use to discuss the figures with someone you were not angry with.

She shows you the two entries. You can see that the total is wrong. You could say:

“Yes, I’ve included it twice. Thanks for catching that. I’ll correct the total.”

You have actively cooperated with checking and correcting the work. That is a different behaviour from attacking her competence. It also gives you information: a correction can be useful even when receiving it feels uncomfortable.

Include what happens afterwards

Suppose you say the right words, then spend the rest of the meeting searching for a mistake in everything she says. The original urge is still organising your behaviour. The next part of practice is to return your attention to the actual discussion when you notice yourself looking for an opportunity to get even.

You may still feel heat in your face or embarrassment about the error. I would review whether you listened, checked the figures and resisted turning the exchange into retaliation. The emotional intensity may take longer to change.

What would change the choice?

If the colleague added, “You never get anything right,” there would be an actual personal remark to address. You could still correct the total and say, “Let’s keep this about the calculation.” A recurring pattern of belittling comments may need a separate conversation or workplace support.

If her correction was wrong, you could explain the figures. Opposite action would not require agreeing with an inaccurate criticism. The useful alternative to attacking is examining and responding to what was actually said.

Example 2: a friend shares something private

A friend posts a personal detail about your health in a group conversation. You had told them privately, and they did not ask whether they could share it.

You are angry about the disclosure. You also know something private about them. The urge is to put that information into the same conversation so they understand how it feels.

Keep the grievance clear

Here, there is no need to search for an interpretation that makes the disclosure acceptable. The information has been shared. Your concern about privacy deserves attention.

I would separate the wish to protect your privacy from the wish to hurt your friend. Revealing their information cannot undo the disclosure. It would create a second breach and give the group more personal information to discuss.

You can combine work on the retaliatory urge with a direct request:

“That was personal information I shared with you privately. Please remove it from the group. I don’t want it discussed here.”

You choose a private conversation for the rest of the issue. You put your friend’s personal information out of the response entirely, and explain the effect on you without trying to humiliate them in return. You describe what you need from them, then let them answer.

The request addresses the problem. The deliberate move away from retaliation—your choice of setting, words and manner—works against the urge to attack. Those are connected decisions with different purposes.

What happens to the anger?

It may remain strong. Trust has been affected, and a deletion may not undo what other people have already seen. Opposite action cannot make those consequences disappear.

You can decide what information you share with this person in future and whether you want more distance. You can also say, “I need you to ask me before sharing anything personal about me.” These decisions do not depend on first feeling warm towards them.

Later, you notice yourself composing the retaliatory message again. You can recognise what is happening: “I’m imagining making them feel exposed.” Then return to the decision you have made and the activity in front of you. If there is a further practical step to take, write it down and carry it out separately from the imagined revenge.

What would change the choice?

An apology and removal of the message would give you different information from mockery or repeated disclosure. You can reconsider the relationship as you learn more. Continuing to share personal information is not part of practising opposite action.

If someone uses personal information to threaten or intimidate you, consider support and safety before further contact. You do not have to stay in an exchange or approach someone unsafe to demonstrate this skill.

What about the argument that continues in your head?

I would look at the difference between working something out and repeatedly rehearsing an attack. Are you deciding what you need to say, or repeatedly imagining a scene in which the other person is defeated?

An unwanted memory can return without your choosing it. The aim is to notice when you have become caught up in the rehearsal and bring your attention back to what you have chosen to do. You do not have to monitor every thought or make your mind go blank.

You can keep a clear record of the facts, decide on a next step and still practise leaving the imagined confrontation unfinished. My article on replaying arguments and anger rumination explores this in more detail.

A short practice to make the skill specific

Choose an incident you can think about clearly, or a recurring situation you can prepare for. Write one sentence for each of these:

  1. The event: what happened, without adding an unverified motive.
  2. The urge: what you wanted to do to the person or situation.
  3. The reason to change it: did the anger seem out of proportion, did checking the facts weaken the interpretation driving it, or would acting on the urge work against what mattered to you?
  4. The alternative: the exact words and behaviour you will use, including how you will speak and what you will pay attention to.
  5. The remaining issue: any request, boundary or practical task that still needs attention.

Afterwards, record what you did and what followed. In the meeting example, “I checked the calculation and corrected it, but kept mentally criticising her” is useful information. It identifies the part of the response to practise next. Also record whether the urge and intensity changed during the attempt or afterwards, and what you will repeat or adjust next time.

Rehearse the words aloud before the next likely situation. The aim is to have a response you can remember when you notice the urge, rather than inventing the whole approach during an argument.

When it does not seem to help

“I behaved differently, but I still felt furious.”

Look separately at what changed in your behaviour and what happened to the feeling. A different action can be an important change even if your body has not settled. Also check whether the situation is still provoking anger. An ongoing privacy breach needs attention beyond repeating an emotion skill.

“I was polite, but they knew I was angry.”

They may notice, and you can acknowledge the feeling. You are using a different response to influence the anger. Check for the parts that continue the attack: sarcasm, contemptuous gestures, repeated accusations or a demand that they first admit defeat. You can be direct about anger while changing those behaviours.

“It feels as if I’m surrendering.”

Name the action you are choosing and the issue you are retaining. “I’m giving up the attempt to embarrass them. I’m keeping my request that the information is removed.” If your version of opposite action requires abandoning your own needs, reconsider the plan.

“I cannot use any of this when I’m that angry.”

Work with an earlier cue, such as beginning to interrupt or searching for an insult. If you are close to acting harmfully, first stop the immediate action: for example, stop typing and put the phone down before sending the message. You can examine the choice when you are able to take in information. Repeated outbursts or concern about hurting someone warrant individual professional support.

What can you reasonably expect?

Opposite action is an established DBT skill, but research on the isolated skill is limited. A small laboratory study involving 16 adults with borderline personality disorder did not find a clear short-term anger advantage for its adapted opposite-action instructions over instructions to act consistently with the emotion. Its brief experimental format limits what it can tell us about everyday practice. 4

I would not promise that one attempt will remove your anger. Look for specific changes: whether you carried out the alternative, whether the urge or intensity changed, and whether you dealt with the actual problem. Those observations give you a basis for deciding what to adjust.

My DBT for anger guide explains how opposite action fits alongside other skills. For the wider picture and options for help in Ireland, see my anger management guide.

Sources

  1. Linehan, M. M. DBT Skills Training Handouts and Worksheets, Second Edition. Guilford Press, 2015. Emotion regulation materials on choosing between opposite action and problem-solving. Publisher’s materials.
  2. Behavioral Tech Institute. The Role of Emotion Regulation in DBT, Part 1. Interview with Sara Schmidt on understandable emotions, factual fit and effectiveness. Read the explanation.
  3. Linehan, M. M. DBT Skills Training Manual, Second Edition. Guilford Press, 2015. Emotion regulation teaching notes on opposite action, participation in the response and troubleshooting. Publisher’s teaching materials.
  4. Sauer-Zavala, S., and colleagues. Isolating the effect of opposite action in borderline personality disorder: a laboratory-based alternating treatment design. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 117, 79–86, 2019. Full research article. doi:10.1016/j.brat.2018.10.006.
Start Anger Management
Start Anger Management Course