You have decided to go to a book group, but on the evening of the meeting you want to cancel. You would like to meet people and discuss something you enjoy. Now you are imagining having nothing to say, feeling awkward and wishing you had stayed at home.
You might wait until you feel more confident before going. Another possibility is to decide, after considering the situation, that you can attend while feeling anxious. You would be changing what you do before you know whether the feeling will change.
DBT calls this kind of response opposite action. It means identifying what an emotion is urging you to do and, when that response is unsuitable, deliberately choosing a different action. It is a skill for influencing emotional responses through behaviour. 1
I learned this approach during specialist training in dialectical behaviour therapy, or DBT, after qualifying as a Doctor of Psychology. I trained as part of a team in the UK health service, working with people with personality disorders and complex emotional difficulties. My work with anger began there.
Before I suggest using the skill, I want to understand the feeling, the urge and the circumstances. Doing the opposite of an urge can help in some situations and be a poor choice in others.
Start with the action you feel like taking
An emotion and an action are different. Fear may come with a desire to leave. Shame may bring a wish to hide. Anger may bring an urge to attack or interrupt. What you actually do is a further part of the response.
The word “opposite” refers to that particular urge. If fear is making you cancel an activity you want to attend, the relevant action might be approaching it. If your angry urge is to insult somebody, the alternative might be to address the issue without the personal attack.
I would ask for a concrete description. “I want to get away from this feeling” leaves several possibilities open. “I want to cancel the meeting and stay home” tells us what behaviour we are considering changing.
The idea is that what you do becomes part of what happens next emotionally. If you cancel the book group, anxiety may drop because you no longer expect to face it. But you have not found out what attending would be like. The next invitation can bring the same predictions. Going into the room, listening and asking a question give you a different experience to respond to. Your attention moves from imagining the meeting to taking part in it. Your posture and physical responses are part of that experience too. This does not guarantee comfort; it gives you information with which to reconsider the fear and your next decision. 2
A decision guide: does opposite action fit?
Two questions guide the decision: does the emotion, including its strength and duration, fit what is happening; and would following its urge help in this situation? DBT allows for opposite action when the emotion does not fit the facts or when acting on the urge would be ineffective. 1
Understanding why a feeling arose is a separate question. A reaction can make sense in the context of your experience without every conclusion or action that follows from it being useful. 2
When there is actual danger or a problem to address
Choose a response that deals with the circumstances. Fear of a threatening person is not a reason to approach them to practise this skill. A needed repair, decision or protective action cannot be replaced by changing your emotional response.
When the urge is taking you in an unhelpful direction
Consider an action that changes that direction. In the book-group example, we would examine the reasons for staying home and whether cancellation serves what you want from the evening.
When both the response and the situation need attention
You can change an unhelpful reaction and still address what happened. For example, refraining from an insult does not mean agreeing to unfair treatment. These options can be combined.
These are decisions to make with the circumstances in view. They are not rules that every unpleasant feeling should be opposed.
Worked example: attending the book group
This example is fictional and was written to explain the skill. It is not an account of a client or a claim about a treatment outcome.
Your local library advertises a group that welcomes new members. You have read the book and would like to join. As the meeting approaches, you imagine being asked a question you cannot answer. Your stomach tightens. You begin composing a message saying you cannot come.
Look at what you know
The group welcomes newcomers. You have an interest in the book. You have no information suggesting that the group is hostile. You also cannot know exactly how the meeting will go.
“I may feel awkward” is possible. “Everyone will think I am foolish” is a prediction. I would not try to replace it with a promise that everyone will like you. There is uncertainty to allow for.
I would also check that you actually want to attend. Opposite action should not become a reason to accept every invitation. In this example, meeting people through a shared interest is something you want, and fear is pulling you towards cancelling.
On those facts, we have a reason to consider approaching the group. If you had previously been mistreated there, that would change the information we were working with.
Choose what approaching will involve
“Be more confident” does not tell you what to do. A more specific plan is to go into the room, introduce yourself to the organiser and join the discussion.
You might prepare a straightforward opening:
“Hello, I’m here for the book group. It’s my first visit.”
For the discussion, you could choose a question you want to ask about the book. That gives your attention somewhere to go beyond evaluating how you are coming across.
The size of the task should fit your starting point. Introducing yourself to the organiser may be the first thing to practise. If you already attend comfortably but always avoid speaking, another silent visit would leave that particular difficulty untouched. In that case, asking a question may be the relevant action.
I would make the choice precise enough that you can tell afterwards whether you attempted it.
Participate in the action you chose
DBT describes practising opposite action “all the way”: attending to the behaviour and to the accompanying words, tone, posture and thinking. This is different from concealing the emotion while continuing to follow its urge. 3
In the example, you could enter the room and then spend the discussion looking at your phone. You would have attended, but the phone might still be helping you avoid contact.
A fuller attempt could involve putting it away, sitting where you can follow the discussion and listening for an opportunity to ask your question. If you are turned away from the group, adjust your position so that joining in is easier. Choose a position that works for your body; there is no requirement to adopt a rigid pose or force eye contact.
Notice the instructions you are giving yourself as well. Repeatedly telling yourself, “Don’t say anything; you’ll sound stupid,” is pulling against the action you planned. You can recognise that prediction and bring your attention back to what the person speaking is actually saying.
An anxious thought may return while you participate. Its presence does not cancel your attempt. The task is to keep engaging with the chosen activity, rather than making the removal of every worried thought a condition for taking part.
Practising fully also does not mean selecting the most difficult possible task. You can work on an appropriate first action and give that action your attention. Agreeing to lead the whole meeting would be a different demand from introducing yourself.
Review what happened without inventing a favourable story
Afterwards, I would want to know what you did and what occurred:
- Did you enter the room, introduce yourself or ask the question you had planned?
- What did people actually say or do?
- When did you feel the urge to withdraw, and what did you do then?
- How did the anxiety change during the visit and afterwards?
You might still have felt tense while doing something you normally avoid. That would tell us something about your behaviour, even if the emotional change was limited. You might also have discovered that the group was not a good fit for you. Both are worth noticing.
The review helps you decide what to repeat, what to change and whether the original choice of skill was appropriate. It should not require you to describe an uncomfortable experience as wonderful.
How the same reasoning can apply to shame and anger
Shame after a minor mistake
Imagine stumbling over a word during a group discussion and then wanting never to return. I would look at what actually happened, how others responded and what withdrawing would mean for you.
If the urge to disappear is out of proportion to a minor mistake, returning to the activity and taking part could be an opposite action. You would be allowing yourself to be present despite feeling embarrassed.
That is different from dismissing harm you have caused. If you have hurt somebody, acknowledging it and making an appropriate repair may be needed. Nor does this skill require disclosing private information to people you have reason not to trust.
Anger and an urge to attack
If anger is pulling you towards a personal insult, an opposite action could be to describe the problem without attacking the person. Your request can remain firm. The issue you are raising does not disappear because you change your delivery.
My article on opposite action for anger works through two situations in detail: responding to accurate criticism and addressing a breach of privacy. The broader guide to DBT for anger explains how this skill fits alongside other approaches.
When an attempt does not help
I would begin by checking the decision, rather than assuming you need to try harder.
Was the situation understood accurately? You may have overlooked information that makes the emotion appropriate. Changing a reaction should not require ignoring evidence.
Did the action address your actual urge? Attending a group while finding ways to avoid every interaction may leave the behaviour you wanted to change largely intact. Equally, the action may have been too demanding for a useful first attempt.
What did the attempt involve? Look at the specific behaviour, where your attention went and what happened afterwards. That gives you more information than describing the entire exercise as a success or failure.
If you are intensely distressed, detailed analysis may be difficult. You can return to these questions when you are able to examine the situation. There is no need to make a difficult emotional episode into a test you must pass.
What does research tell us about opposite action?
Research on the skill by itself is limited. A pilot study involving five women with borderline personality disorder explored an intervention for shame about a particular event. Its findings were encouraging, but that small study cannot establish how well the skill works across emotions or populations. 4
A later laboratory study involved 16 people with borderline personality disorder. Acting opposite to an induced emotion produced greater short-term reductions than acting consistently with it for sadness and guilt/shame, but not for anxiety or anger. The authors highlighted limitations of the laboratory adaptation and the need for further research in everyday settings. 5
Those findings support a careful description: opposite action is a DBT skill with a clinical rationale and some direct research, rather than a technique that has been shown to work equally well for every emotion. Evidence for a complete DBT programme should not be treated as proof of what this single exercise will achieve.
Choosing a first practice
Choose a situation that you feel able to examine and an activity you actually want to approach or a reaction you want to change. Write down the urge, why you are considering a different response and what you intend to do. Afterwards, record what happened, including anything that changed your understanding of the situation.
Practise and review the response on suitable occasions; you are not required to remain in a situation until the feeling disappears.
If fear, shame or other intense emotions repeatedly restrict your life, professional assessment can help you choose an appropriate treatment. This article explains one skill. My introduction to dialectical behaviour therapy describes the wider approach.
Sources
- Linehan, M. M. DBT Skills Training Handouts and Worksheets, Second Edition. Guilford Press, 2015. Emotion regulation handouts on checking the facts, opposite action and problem-solving. Publisher’s materials.
- Behavioral Tech Institute. The Role of Emotion Regulation in DBT, Part 1. Interview with Sara Schmidt, PhD. Emotional validation, factual fit and effectiveness.
- Linehan, M. M. DBT Skills Training Manual, Second Edition. Guilford Press, 2015. Emotion regulation teaching notes, including opposite action and its distinction from suppressing emotion. Publisher’s teaching materials.
- Rizvi, S. L., & Linehan, M. M. The treatment of maladaptive shame in borderline personality disorder: A pilot study of “opposite action.” Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 12(4), 437–447, 2005. Research abstract at Rutgers University. doi:10.1016/S1077-7229(05)80071-9.
- Sauer-Zavala, S., and colleagues. Isolating the effect of opposite action in borderline personality disorder: A laboratory-based alternating treatment design. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 117, 79–86, 2019. Full research article. doi:10.1016/j.brat.2018.10.006.
