Dr Elaine RyanDoctor of PsychologyStart Panic Course
Menu

Insights from Dr Elaine Ryan

Panic Attacks Coming Back: How to Respond to a Setback

One of the most discouraging thoughts in panic recovery is, “It is coming back.” You may have been getting on with your life for months, then feel a familiar racing heart or rush of fear. It can be tempting to judge all your progress by that one frightening moment.

I would look at what is happening over time before deciding what it means. One attack does not tell you that everything you learned has gone. Equally, if attacks are becoming frequent or you are avoiding more of your life, that deserves attention. This article is about responding to returning panic and making use of the work you have already done. My main panic guide explains symptoms and treatment if you need to revisit the background.

Signs that panic is affecting your life again

A setback may show up in your routines as well as in your symptoms. Perhaps you are taking a longer route to avoid a particular road, asking someone to accompany you again, or spending more of the evening checking how your body feels. Cancelling one plan does not necessarily mean that your panic is getting worse. Look for a pattern that is beginning to limit you.

Choose one or two changes you have noticed rather than monitoring every sensation. You could write, “I used to go to the local shop on my own; this week I have asked someone to come each time.” That gives you something specific to work on. “I am failing again” gives you a judgement, but little direction.

Does another attack mean you are back where you started?

There is a difference between “I had a panic attack yesterday” and “I will never be able to go out again.” The first describes an event. The second is a prediction about your future. It can feel convincing when it brings back memories of a difficult period.

If these are familiar symptoms that have been assessed, you might remind yourself of what you learned previously: what happened when you stayed with the sensations, what helped you stop checking, or which activities you regained. You do not have to feel completely convinced before considering that evidence.

Sleep, meals and the demands on your time

Look at what has changed recently. Poor sleep, extra demands, illness or a loss of routine may be relevant, although there is not always one identifiable reason. This is a practical review, not a search for something you did wrong.

Start with something you can change: eating regularly, going to bed at a more consistent time, talking to a friend or returning to an exercise that helped during treatment. If caffeine has increased, consider whether it is contributing. If you may be dependent on alcohol or have withdrawal symptoms, get medical advice before cutting down or stopping. Do not change prescribed medication on your own.

If you are recovering from illness or have ongoing physical symptoms, adapt activity with medical advice. A plan for panic should not require you to push through an illness or disregard restrictions you have been given.

Getting back to an activity you have started avoiding

Think of an activity you have stopped doing because you fear another attack. Start with a part you feel able to try, using what helped you before. If you are working with a therapist, discuss where to begin. You do not have to start with the hardest thing you used to do or repeat the whole treatment programme.

For example, suppose you had returned to shopping independently but have started avoiding the checkout after an attack. You could start by buying one item in a familiar shop. Before going, write down what you predict: “If I feel shaky while paying, I will be unable to finish.” Afterwards, record what actually happened. You might still have felt shaky and completed the purchase. That is useful information even if you were not calm throughout.

If that is too difficult, try something easier and build from there. The exposure therapy explanation describes the approach. Choose what to try based on the particular thing you fear will happen.

Look at checking and reassurance

You may notice an old habit returning: repeatedly checking your pulse, searching symptoms after every sensation or asking the same question until you feel certain. My article on safety behaviours explains why these actions can give brief relief while keeping the fear unresolved.

Start with one habit. For someone whose pulse checking is only a reassurance habit, that might mean putting attention back on the conversation instead of checking again. This does not apply to monitoring prescribed for a health condition. The same action can have a different purpose for different people.

When symptoms feel different

If a symptom is different from your usual panic, check it with your GP.

For symptoms that have already been assessed, it can help to agree with your GP when you should seek another review and what you can manage using your panic plan. That gives you a clearer basis for decisions than either checking repeatedly or trying to ignore every concern. If medication has recently changed, tell the prescriber about the symptoms rather than assuming they are a relapse.

Make room for what is happening in your life

It is harder to practise when you are grieving, caring for someone, ill or under pressure at work. A realistic plan takes those demands into account. You might need practical help with a responsibility as well as time to work on panic.

You may need rest, particularly after illness. It is also worth noticing if you are putting off things you could otherwise do because you are waiting to feel completely calm. If it is hard to tell the difference, discuss it with your clinician.

Tell someone what kind of support would help

You might say, “I’m worried the panic is coming back. I could do with a bit of help.” Be specific about the help you want: company while you organise an appointment, a chance to talk, or encouragement with an agreed practice.

Support does not have to mean asking another person to guarantee that nothing will happen. Nor does becoming more independent mean refusing all company. The aim is to make ordinary choices possible again, with support that suits your circumstances.

When to return for professional help

You can contact your GP or therapist when you notice the difficulty, rather than waiting for it to become severe. Frequent attacks, increasing avoidance, disrupted sleep or difficulty managing work and daily responsibilities are reasons to ask for a review.

The review can look at what has changed, what helped before and whether your treatment plan needs adapting. CBT for panic attacks is one established option. The amount and kind of help needed varies; a returning symptom does not tell us how many sessions someone will need.

Write a short plan you can actually use

Keep it brief enough to refer to when you are worried. You could use these questions:

  • What change have I noticed in everyday life?
  • What did I learn or practise previously that could help here?
  • What will I try, and when?
  • What support or medical advice do I need?
  • When will I look back at how it went?

For the shopping example, the plan might be to buy one item during an ordinary visit, then make a short note afterwards about the prediction and outcome. Use what happened to decide what you want to try next. There is no requirement to complete a harder task every day or to feel recovered by the end of a week.

What counts as progress now?

Look at the choices you are regaining as well as how you feel. Completing a task while anxious, spending less time seeking reassurance, or asking for useful help can all matter. A difficult day can tell you where the plan needs adjusting without defining the whole of your recovery.

If you are still unsettled immediately after an attack, my guide to the first 24 hours afterwards is the more useful place to start. You can think about what to do next when you feel more settled.

Sources

Start Panic Course
Start Panic Course